President Bola Tinubu may believe that judges cannot hold the scale of justice steady with empty pockets. But Nigeria needs to be reminded that justice is not a business transaction, judicial integrity is not for sale, and the conscience of a judge must never be measured by the thickness of his wallet.
Yes, judges deserve decent salaries. Yes, they deserve comfortable working conditions. And yes, a judiciary struggling with poor funding and inadequate infrastructure cannot function at its best. But to suggest that the delivery of justice depends on how much money judges take home is to dangerously confuse welfare with integrity and financial comfort with judicial independence.
A judge does not need a fat bank account to know right from wrong. He needs the courage to do right, even when the consequences are unpleasant.
Tinubu’s 300 per cent increase in judicial salaries and allowances under the Judicial Office Holders (Salaries and Allowances, Etc.) Act, 2024, may be a welcome intervention. But it is certainly not a certificate of judicial independence, neither is it proof that justice in Nigeria has suddenly become stronger, faster or more accessible.
The President must understand that judicial independence cannot be bought with salary increases. It is guaranteed by the Constitution, protected by institutional safeguards and sustained by the courage of judges to resist political intimidation and executive interference.
The real question is not how much judges earn. It is whether they can deliver judgments against the President, his ministers, his political associates and the ruling party without fear of retaliation.
That is the real test\!
Tinubu says his administration respects court judgments, even those it does not enjoy reading. Fine words. But respect for the judiciary is not demonstrated at birthday celebrations, public lectures or book presentations. It is demonstrated when a court delivers an inconvenient judgment and the government obeys it without hesitation, manipulation or subtle attempts to undermine the institution.
The President’s own political history is replete with legal battles in which the courts played decisive roles. From the struggle against the military’s dissolution of the National Assembly in 1993 to the dispute over Lagos State’s local government allocations during his governorship, Tinubu knows the value of an independent judiciary when political power is used against him.
His administration has also benefited from the courts’ intervention in constitutional disputes, including the landmark July 2024 Supreme Court judgment affirming the financial autonomy of local governments.
But judicial independence cannot be celebrated only when it produces favourable outcomes. It must be defended even when the courts rule against the government of the day.
And there lies the challenge for Tinubu.
The judiciary must never become an institution that looks towards Aso Rock for financial favours or political approval. Judges are not presidential appointees in the sense of being political loyalists. Their constitutional responsibilities are owed to the Nigerian people, not to the generosity of whoever occupies the presidential villa.
Indeed, there is something deeply troubling about presenting improved judicial remuneration as a major demonstration of commitment to justice. Judges’ salaries are not presidential gifts. They are legitimate entitlements paid from public funds. The President is not doing judges a personal favour by approving what the law provides.
Besides, what happens to the millions of Nigerians whose pockets are also empty?
What about the poor man who cannot afford a lawyer? What about the widow who spends years pursuing an inheritance case? What about citizens who languish in detention because their trials have become endless journeys through an inefficient judicial system? What about the innocent accused persons whose lives are ruined by prolonged trials?
Must they also wait for their pockets to become full before they can obtain justice?
The greatest crisis confronting Nigeria’s judiciary is not simply poor remuneration. It is the growing public perception that justice is slow, expensive and sometimes accessible only to those with money and influence.
A judiciary that pays its judges handsomely but leaves ordinary Nigerians unable to access justice has missed the point.
And let nobody mistake improved salaries for improved integrity. Higher pay does not automatically produce honest judges, just as poverty does not automatically produce corrupt ones. A judge who lacks integrity can compromise justice regardless of the number of zeros in his monthly salary.
If anything, better remuneration should come with greater responsibility, stronger accountability and zero tolerance for judicial corruption.
The President should therefore concentrate less on the size of judges’ pockets and more on strengthening the institutions that protect them from political pressure. He should ensure transparent judicial appointments, respect the financial and administrative independence of the courts, improve court infrastructure and guarantee that judicial decisions are obeyed without selective compliance.
Most importantly, he must resist every temptation to treat the judiciary as an appendage of the executive.
A judiciary that fears the President cannot protect the people. A judge who fears losing his financial comfort cannot be trusted to defend the Constitution. And a government that confuses generous salaries with judicial independence has not understood the meaning of justice.
Tinubu deserves credit for the 300 per cent salary increase. But he must not confuse a better-paid judiciary with a better judiciary.
Nigeria does not merely need judges with full pockets. It needs judges with full courage, clean hands and uncompromising consciences.
For at the end of the day, justice is not delivered by the size of a pay cheque. It is delivered by the strength of character of the person holding the gavel.
Judges don’t need full pockets to deliver justice. They need the courage to dispense it, even when the powerful are the ones standing in the dock.
By Emmanuel Emeke Asiwe(EEA), Publisher/Editor-in-Chief